Punishment for defending one’s innocence: An examination of probation responses

Animal activism – Does the end justify the means?
August 6, 2021
Public perceptions of the role of the Police Community Support Officer
August 6, 2021

Punishment for defending one’s innocence: An examination of probation responses

Miscarriages of Justice

Maybe you are more interested in the justice system and the miscarriages of justice specifically. If so, please review the below suggestions and see if they help:

Example miscarriages of justice dissertation topic 1:

Punishment for defending one’s innocence: An examination of probation responses

Within the criminal justice process one has the right to appeal against conviction. However, if sentenced to a community order or other form of rehabilitation programme involving the probation service there is not only a presumption of guilt but also penalties for continuing to protest one’s innocence. These can include being put on a higher ‘at risk’ register involving more meetings with officers, and being taken back to court for re-sentence for ‘failing to co-operate’ (refusal to admit guilt being a refusal to co-operate). Using case studies form the greater Southampton area this is a dissertation that combines qualitative and quantitative research.

Suggested initial topic reading:

  • Hudson, B. (2001) ‘Human rights, public safety and the Probation Service: Defending justice in the risk society’, The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, Vol. 40, pp. 103-113.
  • Nash, M. (1996) ‘Consumers without teeth: Can probation service “clients” have a say in the service they receive?’ International Journal of Public Sector Management, Vol. 9(4), pp.12-19.
  • Nellis, M. (2002) ‘Community justice, time and the new National Probation Service’, The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice, Vol. 41, pp. 59-86.